Sunday, 19 October 2014

Movie VS Book: Gone Girl



Finally, after a busy week of submitting final assignments and completing exams, I was able sit down and watch Gillian Flynn’s ‘Gone Girl’.

One of my first posts actually included my personal review of the book. I absolutely adored the novel. It was heavily layered with brilliantly written, complex characters and the suspenseful and twisted story line continually kept me guessing. The novel was extremely addictive; drowned in scandals, narcissistic and sociopathic tales, which made it utterly thrilling and quite dark to say the least.  With this in mind, I was so excited to see how the story line would be reflected on the big screen.

What I was particularly happy to see in the film adaption was how often the exact text of the book was recited, especially the sections from Amy’s diary which included many clues and haunting recounts.  As the language in the book was so incredibly unique, descriptive, thought provoking and insightful, I am SO glad to see that this element was not overlooked.

Additionally, the movie was really accurate with the book. It included all the main events; in fact, I’m struggling to recall some of the ones they forget to mention. I was even surprised they included the gummy bear scene! This was definitely a film where I found myself thinking that yes, some movies can be just as good as the book.  

I was so happy to see my favourite character Go, was just as colourful, witty and bluntly honest as she was in the book. In fact, the casting was pretty much spot on for each of the characters. This aspect definitely assisted in making the plot just as deliciously unexpected and thrilling as the book.

I was initially skeptical when I heard Ben Affleck would be taking on the role of Nick Dunne, but I was pleasantly surprised! Since watching it, I could not think of someone better suited. He perfectly adopted the role of the weary yet fiercely resentful husband. Additionally, Rosamund Pike pretty much stole the show as Amy Dunne; she left me speechless. She executed the role of the perfectionist, intelligent young woman; plagued by the overbearing obsession with seeking evil forms of revenge seamlessly.

If I had to choose one character in particular that I probably would have cast differently, it would have to be Neil Patrick Harris as Desi Collings. Perhaps it was my own personal interpretation of Desi when I read the novel that caused me to be somewhat displeased with the casting choice. I perceived Desi to be incredibly shy yet sternly possessive and creepier as a character.  The book allowed for more detail when it came to Amy and Desi’s relationship and the inhumane actions she was going to take to frame her escape.  

Part of me was disappointed that director, David Fincher did not alter the ending of the film.  I was totally surprised by the ending in the book, considering the relationship Nick and Amy Dunne had following her disappearance. Although, in saying this, I did appreciate how there was more reasoning and a deeper explanation in the film in comparison to the book as to why Nick chose to stay with Amy. 

As the movie obviously could not go on for hours upon hours, it did lack the deep level of suspense and questioning that the book offered. I do really recommend reading the book beforehand, just because the story line is fantastically detailed and complex (I cannot stress this enough); diving head first into the nitty gritty of Amy’s disappearance.  

This movie is a cynical portrayal of the sexes and marriage. Although it is the dark, funny and brutal signs of the characters madness that make it so unforgettable. 

Short review of Gillian Flynn's 'Gone Girl': http://australian-living-abroad.blogspot.sg/2014_02_01_archive.html

No comments:

Post a Comment